Trophy search revives memories of a tragic disappearance

Men's prem 8+ (13)

One man finally finds some closure after an incident on Wellington Harbour nearly 60 years ago claimed the life of a rising rowing personality.

 

February 20, 2025

Chris and Rosenda Upton step into the Volunteer Centre at the New Zealand Rowing Championships at Lake Ruataniwha looking for a steer.

They’ve come to take a photo of a famous trophy and being new to rowing aren’t sure who to ask.

Their daughter Lottie is at her first nationals for Petone and is part of the St Oran’s College programme that has just started its first ever season in the sport.

Chris and Rosenda want to take the photo on behalf of a friend of theirs, a longtime member of their parish and a man running out of time.

March 30, 1968

It’s around 5pm on a Saturday afternoon in late summer, the sun getting low over Wellington Harbour and Dick Joyce has asked coxswain Alan Boykett along to help him coach the Victoria University Eight ahead of Easter tournament. They’re in a coach boat called the ‘Chelp’ borrowed from Wellington Rowing Club.

“It was a terrible old machine,” says Dick. “It was a thing called a Plylite [but] it was hardly light, it took 10 men to put the blazing thing in the water...it had a terrible old McCulloch outboard motor on the back of it.

“Anyway, we put this thing on the water and Alan was sitting up in the bow and I was trying to get this motor to run properly because it was only running on one cylinder, I was trying to identify which cylinder wasn’t working so that I could whip the [spark] plug out, clean it and put it back in.

“We were doing only three or four, maybe five knots. We came round the outside of the then Taranaki Street Wharf...I was still leaning over the motor trying to figure out which plug was good, and which wasn't and there was this God Almighty bang.

“Everything went upside down. I flipped [the boat] onto its back and realised Alan wasn’t on the surface, so I started looking for him immediately, I did two or three dives trying to find  him...the eight had launched and was not far away, so I yelled for them to come over...there were three or four of us diving, looking for Alan.

“My guess is he got a whack on the head as the boat came over the top of us and he simply  went straight to the bottom.

“The Police launch Lady Elizabeth came alongside and my face had a beautiful black hole  in it where I'd gone down on top of the flywheel. So they ordered me out of the water.”

 

March 12, 2025

Lance Hurly has never forgotten the moment he learned of his mate’s disappearance nearly 60 years ago.

“ We were round at the Boykett family home,” says Lance. “We'd been doing our own other things, by that stage, I'd met my future wife [and] we were having a big party there, and Alan was off rowing. We were just waiting for Alan to come and to continue the party and up their driveway walks a young constable who we all knew because he was a local...he’d to come to break the news to the family, and that was just absolutely devastating, because at that stage they were still searching for a body.”

Lance and Alan were firm friends from the day they met as third formers at Naenae College.

Lance remembers Alan being at Naenae for only a short time before leaving in the fourth form to move to Palmerston North to work for well-known horse trainer Theo Howe.

That was never going to stick though, as Olympic gold medallist John Hunter, who rowed with Alan at Wellington RC, remembers it.

“There was a story going round that his father thought he could be a jockey because he was quite small and he got him into somewhere he could train to be a jockey...but it turned out he was terrified of horses!”

But Alan did have an affinity with coaching and coxing.

In 1967, he coxed Wellington to its first ever Championship Eights victory at Nationals on Lake Waihola.

WellingtonEight1967

Coxswain Alan Boykett at the helm of the Wellington RC eight that won the NZ Championship in 1967: Graham Shaw is in stroke seat, John Hunter (7), Tom Just (6), Peter Delaney (5), Cameron Shaw (4), Bill Page (3), Jeff Brough (2), Tim Dobbie (bow seat).

“His nickname was Bok, he had a way of commanding the crew,” says stroke Graham Shaw. “He was a gregarious, fun personality, always friendly...a guy that everybody enjoyed the company of, and he seemed to enjoy everybody's company as well.  He wasn't a moody guy, he just had a great personality and was perfect in the role.”

Five of that Wellington crew, Alan, Graham, John Hunter, Tom Just and Peter Delaney were rewarded with selection into the first New Zealand Eight to race at the North American Championships at St Catharine’s in Canada in August that year.

Their performance is often regarded as the beginning of New Zealand’s rise to eights dominance in world rowing. The crew, coached by Rusty Robertson, had never raced together in competition until their heat.

NZEight1967

The New Zealand Eight of 1967 after winning the North American Championships at St Catharine’s in Canada: Stroke Alan Webster receives his medal, Wybo Veldman (7), Alistair Dryden (6), John Hunter (5), Gil Cawood (4), Tom Just (3), Graham Shaw (2), Peter Delaney (bow seat), Alan Boykett.

In the final they beat Australia and the world record-holding West German crew rowing under the Ratzeburg club banner, to win gold in 6.02.41. The crew from Harvard, representing the USA was fourth. It was a huge dent to American rowing pride at the time.

“In some respects,” says John, “that's the best [eight] I rowed in. I rowed in the eight for five years and that was possibly the best crew to row in...not necessarily the fastest, but the best to row in.”

It was huge news in world rowing at the time. The Kiwi crew’s upset victory made the New York Times and the middle section of the biggest-selling sports magazine in the world at the time.

“It was August 1967,” says Graham. “And the month of August in Sports Illustrated, if you got into the centre of Sports Illustrated, it was like world rockstar status...people couldn't believe it.”

Untitled design (16)

The Sports Illustrated feature in the August 21 edition featuring the crew that helped launch the legend of New Zealand eight-oared rowing.

April 10, 1968

As the search for Alan continued, another bigger tragedy unfolded on Wellington Harbour.

Sailing out of Lyttelton, the inter-island ferry Wahine, carrying 741 passengers and crew was nearing Wellington when it was caught in the vortex of two massive storms meeting head on in Cook Strait.

The Wahine was blown onto Barrett Reef and over the course of the next 8 hours, it capsized then sank. Fifty-three people (two later from injuries sustained in the disaster) died, with six bodies never recovered.

ls2-2080x1170 (1)

“Everyone was hopeful that [Alan’s] body would be unearthed by the storm,” says Lance. “But it never was. When they had a memorial service for him at a church in Lower Hutt, it was just eerie because I had never encountered a memorial service where you didn't have a body.  The New Zealand Rowing Eight was there with their coach...it was really hard going.

“That's a moment that really changed my life...that things can happen so unexpectedly.”

For many years Lance worked in the capital. His daily commute became a vigil as well.

“I was catching the train into Wellington and always sitting on that side of the train looking out to the harbour, always looking out of the window and always hoping above hope that something might happen.”

 

February 22, 2025

Mens Pre 8+ winners Avon

Annabel Wynn-Williams and the Avon crew after winning the Premier Eight at the NZ Rowing Championships in February.

Seven members of Avon’s Premier Eight win their first Red Coats, including coxswain Annabel Wynn-Williams.

She’s presented with the Alan Boykett Trophy, gifted by Alan’s family in his honour and awarded to the winning coxswain of the Men’s Championship Eight. Sam Bosworth’s name is engraved on it, so is Caleb Shepherd’s. There’s Rachel Goudie, Matt Cameron, five-time winner Jenny Lysaght from Avon, Alan Cotter, Andrew Bird, and the inaugural winner Simon Dickie.

April 3, 2025

“You know, when you are effectively in control of the boat, and you have an accident like  that and the only passenger aboard gets killed, of course you take responsibility for it, so yeah, I often think about poor Alan.”

  • Dick Joyce

 March 30, 1968

“The speedboat came out and cut the boat in half and Alan just never floated up.  There was no such thing as life jackets in those days.  We searched for bloody days, diving in the water, looking for him. After a couple of weeks it became obvious that Alan, you know, there was all these theories about how long it takes a body to float up after it sunk  and this sort of thing, and then we'd go out again  to try and see if he'd floated up, but he never did.

“And that's where my theory came that if he did sink down, he was then buried in the reclamation work that was going on at the Taranaki Street wharf which was not far away from where they were.”

  • Graham Shaw

April 23, 2025

Annabel Wynn-Williams is just about to turn 20 and is studying engineering at Canterbury University. She started coxing at Rangi Ruru Girls’ School in 2019. She won the Levin Jubilee Trophy with Rangi in 2021 and 2022. From there she made the New Zealand Under 19 Women’s Eight two years running.

Her most recent success came at University Champs at Ruataniwha over Easter, where she helmed University of Canterbury to victory in the Men’s Championship Eight to reclaim the famous Hebberley Shield.

It’s easy to forget that all those races are the exclamation mark of a campaign that can be weeks or months long.  That win for Avon at Nationals, the Red Coat and the Boykett trophy reward for a lot of learning in the boat.

“I think just like with my experience that I've had, my exposure to obviously some really good coaches and other athletes has meant that I've been able to be a better coach on the water and gain a lot more knowledge about how to read a race and I guess hold people accountable to splits and reset when needed.”

The Alan Boykett Trophy is proudly sitting at her flat in Christchurch.

BoykettTrophy1

I asked her if she could record a small message with the trophy for Lance. He’s never seen it in real life.

April 28, 2025

Lance Hurly is gravely ill in  hospital. Annabel's video has been sent as well as a picture of the Boykett trophy.

We hope he finds some peace in this tribute to Alan Boykett.

April 3, 2025

Graham Shaw often looks out to the spot where Alan went missing.

“ I can't say that I go there to remember Alan, but I do go there funnily enough every morning because I walk my dog around there, and I often think of Alan when I'm down there because the exact position where the accident happened is still there.”

Graham’s voice tails off and there’s the long pause of someone reliving all the memories of that day and the years that followed. And then just one word.

“Yeah”. You can only know what that one word in that moment sounds like when you hear it.

Alan Boykett had been selected to compete at the Mexico Olympics just two weeks before he died.

Last year Alan's two sisters were presented with his Rowing New Zealand Legacy medal at a function at Wellington Rowing Club. Alan is recipient number 100.

 

Post script: In a deposition to the Coroner’s inquest in July 1968, Alan Bryan Lockie, the driver of the boat which hit the ‘Chelp’ said that just before the collision “the boat was not travelling fast as it was just picking up speed after having nearly been stopped at the reclamation area”.

He had been showing a friend from Melbourne “points of interest” out on the harbour. 

The ‘Lady Linda’ was a 15-foot runabout with a 65-horsepower outboard motor.

Lockie was not able to say exactly how fast he was going but he did know “I was not doing 15 m.p.h (approx 15 knots) because at this speed my boat starts to plane and we most certainly were not planing at the time of the collision”.

“At the time of the collision I was within 200 yards of the shore or wharf and visibility was not good. The visibility was not good because I was driving into the glare of the sun and everything seemed to look orange in colour.”   

In a later deposition Mr Lockie asked to clarify his previous statement “that I was driving into the glare of the sun”.

“The visibility was excellent with the exception of the line of the sun coming from the port bow quarter. This was the line from which the other vessel came.”

Shaun-Hayward-Andy-Hay-gs-e1675209399782

Andy Hay

Andy Hay is a freelance producer, writer and rowing coach. He was cox of the world champion New Zealand eight of 1982 and '83. He is NZ Olympian #446.

Share Story

Trophy search revives memories of a tragic disappearance

Men's prem 8+ (13)

One man finally finds some closure after an incident on Wellington Harbour nearly 60 years ago claimed the life of a rising rowing personality.

 

February 20, 2025

Chris and Rosenda Upton step into the Volunteer Centre at the New Zealand Rowing Championships at Lake Ruataniwha looking for a steer.

They’ve come to take a photo of a famous trophy and being new to rowing aren’t sure who to ask.

Their daughter Lottie is at her first nationals for Petone and is part of the St Oran’s College programme that has just started its first ever season in the sport.

Chris and Rosenda want to take the photo on behalf of a friend of theirs, a longtime member of their parish and a man running out of time.

March 30, 1968

It’s around 5pm on a Saturday afternoon in late summer, the sun getting low over Wellington Harbour and Dick Joyce has asked coxswain Alan Boykett along to help him coach the Victoria University Eight ahead of Easter tournament. They’re in a coach boat called the ‘Chelp’ borrowed from Wellington Rowing Club.

“It was a terrible old machine,” says Dick. “It was a thing called a Plylite [but] it was hardly light, it took 10 men to put the blazing thing in the water...it had a terrible old McCulloch outboard motor on the back of it.

“Anyway, we put this thing on the water and Alan was sitting up in the bow and I was trying to get this motor to run properly because it was only running on one cylinder, I was trying to identify which cylinder wasn’t working so that I could whip the [spark] plug out, clean it and put it back in.

“We were doing only three or four, maybe five knots. We came round the outside of the then Taranaki Street Wharf...I was still leaning over the motor trying to figure out which plug was good, and which wasn't and there was this God Almighty bang.

“Everything went upside down. I flipped [the boat] onto its back and realised Alan wasn’t on the surface, so I started looking for him immediately, I did two or three dives trying to find  him...the eight had launched and was not far away, so I yelled for them to come over...there were three or four of us diving, looking for Alan.

“My guess is he got a whack on the head as the boat came over the top of us and he simply  went straight to the bottom.

“The Police launch Lady Elizabeth came alongside and my face had a beautiful black hole  in it where I'd gone down on top of the flywheel. So they ordered me out of the water.”

 

March 12, 2025

Lance Hurly has never forgotten the moment he learned of his mate’s disappearance nearly 60 years ago.

“ We were round at the Boykett family home,” says Lance. “We'd been doing our own other things, by that stage, I'd met my future wife [and] we were having a big party there, and Alan was off rowing. We were just waiting for Alan to come and to continue the party and up their driveway walks a young constable who we all knew because he was a local...he’d to come to break the news to the family, and that was just absolutely devastating, because at that stage they were still searching for a body.”

Lance and Alan were firm friends from the day they met as third formers at Naenae College.

Lance remembers Alan being at Naenae for only a short time before leaving in the fourth form to move to Palmerston North to work for well-known horse trainer Theo Howe.

That was never going to stick though, as Olympic gold medallist John Hunter, who rowed with Alan at Wellington RC, remembers it.

“There was a story going round that his father thought he could be a jockey because he was quite small and he got him into somewhere he could train to be a jockey...but it turned out he was terrified of horses!”

But Alan did have an affinity with coaching and coxing.

In 1967, he coxed Wellington to its first ever Championship Eights victory at Nationals on Lake Waihola.

WellingtonEight1967

Coxswain Alan Boykett at the helm of the Wellington RC eight that won the NZ Championship in 1967: Graham Shaw is in stroke seat, John Hunter (7), Tom Just (6), Peter Delaney (5), Cameron Shaw (4), Bill Page (3), Jeff Brough (2), Tim Dobbie (bow seat).

“His nickname was Bok, he had a way of commanding the crew,” says stroke Graham Shaw. “He was a gregarious, fun personality, always friendly...a guy that everybody enjoyed the company of, and he seemed to enjoy everybody's company as well.  He wasn't a moody guy, he just had a great personality and was perfect in the role.”

Five of that Wellington crew, Alan, Graham, John Hunter, Tom Just and Peter Delaney were rewarded with selection into the first New Zealand Eight to race at the North American Championships at St Catharine’s in Canada in August that year.

Their performance is often regarded as the beginning of New Zealand’s rise to eights dominance in world rowing. The crew, coached by Rusty Robertson, had never raced together in competition until their heat.

NZEight1967

The New Zealand Eight of 1967 after winning the North American Championships at St Catharine’s in Canada: Stroke Alan Webster receives his medal, Wybo Veldman (7), Alistair Dryden (6), John Hunter (5), Gil Cawood (4), Tom Just (3), Graham Shaw (2), Peter Delaney (bow seat), Alan Boykett.

In the final they beat Australia and the world record-holding West German crew rowing under the Ratzeburg club banner, to win gold in 6.02.41. The crew from Harvard, representing the USA was fourth. It was a huge dent to American rowing pride at the time.

“In some respects,” says John, “that's the best [eight] I rowed in. I rowed in the eight for five years and that was possibly the best crew to row in...not necessarily the fastest, but the best to row in.”

It was huge news in world rowing at the time. The Kiwi crew’s upset victory made the New York Times and the middle section of the biggest-selling sports magazine in the world at the time.

“It was August 1967,” says Graham. “And the month of August in Sports Illustrated, if you got into the centre of Sports Illustrated, it was like world rockstar status...people couldn't believe it.”

Untitled design (16)

The Sports Illustrated feature in the August 21 edition featuring the crew that helped launch the legend of New Zealand eight-oared rowing.

April 10, 1968

As the search for Alan continued, another bigger tragedy unfolded on Wellington Harbour.

Sailing out of Lyttelton, the inter-island ferry Wahine, carrying 741 passengers and crew was nearing Wellington when it was caught in the vortex of two massive storms meeting head on in Cook Strait.

The Wahine was blown onto Barrett Reef and over the course of the next 8 hours, it capsized then sank. Fifty-three people (two later from injuries sustained in the disaster) died, with six bodies never recovered.

ls2-2080x1170 (1)

“Everyone was hopeful that [Alan’s] body would be unearthed by the storm,” says Lance. “But it never was. When they had a memorial service for him at a church in Lower Hutt, it was just eerie because I had never encountered a memorial service where you didn't have a body.  The New Zealand Rowing Eight was there with their coach...it was really hard going.

“That's a moment that really changed my life...that things can happen so unexpectedly.”

For many years Lance worked in the capital. His daily commute became a vigil as well.

“I was catching the train into Wellington and always sitting on that side of the train looking out to the harbour, always looking out of the window and always hoping above hope that something might happen.”

 

February 22, 2025

Mens Pre 8+ winners Avon

Annabel Wynn-Williams and the Avon crew after winning the Premier Eight at the NZ Rowing Championships in February.

Seven members of Avon’s Premier Eight win their first Red Coats, including coxswain Annabel Wynn-Williams.

She’s presented with the Alan Boykett Trophy, gifted by Alan’s family in his honour and awarded to the winning coxswain of the Men’s Championship Eight. Sam Bosworth’s name is engraved on it, so is Caleb Shepherd’s. There’s Rachel Goudie, Matt Cameron, five-time winner Jenny Lysaght from Avon, Alan Cotter, Andrew Bird, and the inaugural winner Simon Dickie.

April 3, 2025

“You know, when you are effectively in control of the boat, and you have an accident like  that and the only passenger aboard gets killed, of course you take responsibility for it, so yeah, I often think about poor Alan.”

  • Dick Joyce

 March 30, 1968

“The speedboat came out and cut the boat in half and Alan just never floated up.  There was no such thing as life jackets in those days.  We searched for bloody days, diving in the water, looking for him. After a couple of weeks it became obvious that Alan, you know, there was all these theories about how long it takes a body to float up after it sunk  and this sort of thing, and then we'd go out again  to try and see if he'd floated up, but he never did.

“And that's where my theory came that if he did sink down, he was then buried in the reclamation work that was going on at the Taranaki Street wharf which was not far away from where they were.”

  • Graham Shaw

April 23, 2025

Annabel Wynn-Williams is just about to turn 20 and is studying engineering at Canterbury University. She started coxing at Rangi Ruru Girls’ School in 2019. She won the Levin Jubilee Trophy with Rangi in 2021 and 2022. From there she made the New Zealand Under 19 Women’s Eight two years running.

Her most recent success came at University Champs at Ruataniwha over Easter, where she helmed University of Canterbury to victory in the Men’s Championship Eight to reclaim the famous Hebberley Shield.

It’s easy to forget that all those races are the exclamation mark of a campaign that can be weeks or months long.  That win for Avon at Nationals, the Red Coat and the Boykett trophy reward for a lot of learning in the boat.

“I think just like with my experience that I've had, my exposure to obviously some really good coaches and other athletes has meant that I've been able to be a better coach on the water and gain a lot more knowledge about how to read a race and I guess hold people accountable to splits and reset when needed.”

The Alan Boykett Trophy is proudly sitting at her flat in Christchurch.

BoykettTrophy1

I asked her if she could record a small message with the trophy for Lance. He’s never seen it in real life.

April 28, 2025

Lance Hurly is gravely ill in  hospital. Annabel's video has been sent as well as a picture of the Boykett trophy.

We hope he finds some peace in this tribute to Alan Boykett.

April 3, 2025

Graham Shaw often looks out to the spot where Alan went missing.

“ I can't say that I go there to remember Alan, but I do go there funnily enough every morning because I walk my dog around there, and I often think of Alan when I'm down there because the exact position where the accident happened is still there.”

Graham’s voice tails off and there’s the long pause of someone reliving all the memories of that day and the years that followed. And then just one word.

“Yeah”. You can only know what that one word in that moment sounds like when you hear it.

Alan Boykett had been selected to compete at the Mexico Olympics just two weeks before he died.

Last year Alan's two sisters were presented with his Rowing New Zealand Legacy medal at a function at Wellington Rowing Club. Alan is recipient number 100.

 

Post script: In a deposition to the Coroner’s inquest in July 1968, Alan Bryan Lockie, the driver of the boat which hit the ‘Chelp’ said that just before the collision “the boat was not travelling fast as it was just picking up speed after having nearly been stopped at the reclamation area”.

He had been showing a friend from Melbourne “points of interest” out on the harbour. 

The ‘Lady Linda’ was a 15-foot runabout with a 65-horsepower outboard motor.

Lockie was not able to say exactly how fast he was going but he did know “I was not doing 15 m.p.h (approx 15 knots) because at this speed my boat starts to plane and we most certainly were not planing at the time of the collision”.

“At the time of the collision I was within 200 yards of the shore or wharf and visibility was not good. The visibility was not good because I was driving into the glare of the sun and everything seemed to look orange in colour.”   

In a later deposition Mr Lockie asked to clarify his previous statement “that I was driving into the glare of the sun”.

“The visibility was excellent with the exception of the line of the sun coming from the port bow quarter. This was the line from which the other vessel came.”

Shaun-Hayward-Andy-Hay-gs-e1675209399782

Andy Hay

Andy Hay is a freelance producer, writer and rowing coach. He was cox of the world champion New Zealand eight of 1982 and '83. He is NZ Olympian #446.

Share Story

Other Stories

Tokyo 2021 July 30-8097 (1) (1)

Full Circle: Phil Wilson’s Road to LA 2028

BSC_7436

After Maadi – Sam Woodgate

default

From 11 beginners to a rowing crew: Geraldine High School’s emerging programme takes flight